South Korea is widely known as one of
the most economically successful
countries in the world with high-tech
Industries and Global brands that make
products sold all around the world over
the past decades it became a true
economic Powerhouse but now despite all
the global success of its Legacy Brands
it looks like South Korea's economic
model is increasingly running out of
steam its economic growth has been
gradually slowing for years and today it
has basically stopped and no one
including South Korea itself expects
that the economy should start growing
again anytime soon so how come that even
with all of South Korea's Global
high-tech Brands is the economy hitting
a wall how could South Korea turn this
around and why does it seem unable to do
that this is the end of South Korea's
economic miracle for a long time the
South Korean economy knew nothing but
growth starting in the 1950s the economy
grew at a lightning pace for nearly
three decades with growth rates still
exceeding 10% per year even as late as
the 1980s and even though growth
eventually began to slow there was
little cause for concern as South Korea
remained wealthy and it continued to
grow averaging 7% GDP growth in the
1990s 4% in the 2000s and 3% in the
2010s but over the past 5 years Grove
has continued to slow down year by year
and the real problem here isn't just
that the Grove has slowed down after all
this happens to all economies at some
point as they get richer instead the
concern is that this slowdown might not
be a temporary slump but rather the new
normal as even the bank of Korea has
publicly warned that the economy may see
no growth at all in the next decade and
it is likely to begin to shrink by the
2040s in other words there is a
widespread and well-founded worry that s
Korea's economy may have finally
exhausted the secret sauce that fueled
its growth for so long and that from now
on the country is on a declining
trajectory where unless things change
every decade will be worse than the one
before and every generation will be
worse off than their parents but how is
that possible if South Korea designs
builds and sells so many high deck
products that are successful all over
the world and that you very likely have
at home as well well from phones to cars
electronics and so much else well this
Paradox does have an explanation but it
requires us to peel back a few layers to
look at how the Korean economic model
actually came to be and how it operates
to this day because the reality is a
little less glamorous than how it's
usually sold you might have heard that
the core of the South Korean economy is
made up of so-called cha balls ginormous
monopolistic Korean corporation ations
usually owned and operated by several
dynastic families that have for
Generations received privileged support
from the state in form of tax breaks
subsidies and generally not having to
play by the same rules as everyone else
thanks to which they were able to build
companies like Samsung and quickly scale
expand their operations and dominate
markets from Europe to North America but
although here is where the explanation
of the Korean Miracle usually ends this
is a very simplified version of the
story and the whole truth is a lot more
complex because just a government
support doesn't entirely explain how
they were able to build massive
corporations in technologically advanced
sectors and in a country with a little
to no industrial or scientific base and
how they were able to catch up and
overtake their American and European
competitors which had Decades of
experience as a head start well a big
part of the reason behind this is that
South Koreans have mastered the art of
the so-called creative imitation doing
what others were doing but better and at
the origin of the South Korea's
high-tech Industries was its ability to
reverse engineer successful Western
Products and to produce similar items
but at a higher quality and lower cost
and the reason they were able to do that
was because on top of tax breaks and
subsidies the cha balls were able to tap
into other crucial resources thank
thanks to the state-owned Energy company
keco they had access to cheap energy
which lowered their costs and South
Korea's rapidly growing population which
more than doubled between the 1950s and
1980s together with the country's
excellent education system and its newly
created workaholic culture provided an
abundance of cheap and qualified labor
equipped with these advantages the
sorean cha balls were able to
essentially copy and then improve most
Western Products and off for them at a
much lower price and often in better
quality this allowed the country to
eventually move to more advanced
products and sectors evolving from
producing textiles and toys to
electronics and computers and also from
Pure imitation to Innovation gradually
improving and perfecting the products
that were originally just cheaper copies
of their Western competitors but this is
also where the problem began because
this strategy only gets you as far and
it only works as long as you have all
the favorable conditions on your side
and as long as you're able to build the
stuff at a lower price but if that
changes you're no longer competitive and
for South Korea most of the advantages
that made it possible gradually went
away after Decades of providing energy
at subsidized prices to domestic Giants
the Korean state-owned Energy company
keco is now burdened with spiraling debt
that has driven it close to bankruptcy
and so the cheap energy that that used
to fuel South Korea's industry is no
longer available and the cheap and
abandoned labor is also not a thing
anymore as the country's population is
now shrinking rather than growing and
its labor force keeps shrinking along
with it but most importantly the chaals
the South Korean industrial Giants that
drove the country's economy and growth
for decades are no longer the same
either while once upon a time there were
hungry Predators who pursued growth at
every cost today they're owned by a
third generation of their former
Founders and according to Professor Park
from the soul National University they
switched from a former growth mindset
born of hunger towards an incumbent
mindset born of comfort and complacency
instead in other words instead of using
the government's support to pursue
aggressive growth as they used to do
they now use it as a shelter from
competition from abroad and to stifle
competition in formal smaller Innovative
companies that could take their market
share at home and while they do continue
to build highquality products the staff
they build today is mostly the same as
they used to build 20 or 30 years ago
and while in the 20th century they
managed to grow by expanding into more
and more sectors that they would
eventually end up dominating in this
hasn't really been happening in the last
20 years anymore South Korea mostly
keeps building new and improved
iterations of the same cars phones and
consumer goods that It produced 20 years
ago as well but it hasn't really been
able to expand into any of the fastest
growing Tech sectors of the past 10 or
20 years which is why in 2012 it led the
world in 36 out of 120 priority
Technologies identified by the Korean
government but in 2020 this has dropped
to just four and unlike before they now
face a brutal competition from China
which uses a similar strategy as South
Korea and which is increasingly
replacing South Korea's former role and
becoming its direct competitor in many
of the sectors that South Korea used to
dominate in other words South Korea is
stuck in a model that originated in
another time more than seven decades ago
and while for a very long time it
delivered incredible results the world
has changed and it just doesn't work
anymore the South Korean government is
not able to support the cha boss in the
same way as once did Finding itself
without its cheap energy and shrinking
population and meanwhile the cha balls
themselves went from being aggressive
predators to bloated corporations that
use their unfair advantage to crush
domestic competition while they're
unable to keep up and break into new
sectors and Technologies now it might
seem like a logical conclusion that this
system desperately needs a change so why
is South Korea not trying to do that
well the problem is that because of how
incredibly successful this model was for
a long time it's now incredibly
difficult for South Korea to let it go
and move on to something else the cha
balls with all their influence and
wealth also don't want to change as that
would necessarily mean taking away their
unfair Privileges and the fact that
South Korea has been stuck in a series
of prolonged political crisis with a
paralyzed political system and an
inability to make any strategic
decisions as a result doesn't help
either but without significant reform
and a willingness to adapt to a new
reality South Korea risks losing its
hard- earned place as an economic
Powerhouse and the question is whether
it will be able to reinvent itself
before it's too late
Comments